The Financial Times, which first reported the legal proceedings, noted that correspondence between the tech firms and eu-LISA suggests the dispute has been simmering for several years. The letters reveal a deteriorating relationship, with the tech companies reportedly accusing the EU agency of "ignoring reality" regarding the feasibility of new deadlines. Conversely, eu-LISA’s internal financial reports have consistently highlighted ongoing difficulties with the IBM-Atos-Leonardo consortium, particularly concerning the delivery of milestones and the management of costs.
Financial Escalation and Contractual Disputes
The financial dimension of the project has seen significant growth since its inception. The original contract value for the development of the EES was set at approximately €142 million. However, as delays mounted and technical requirements evolved, the cost of the project surged. By 2021, the contract value had been adjusted to €212 million, representing a nearly 50% increase in the budget allocated to the consortium.
Despite this injection of capital, the relationship between the agency and its primary contractors reached a breaking point. The annual reports from eu-LISA underscore the agency’s frustration, noting that the activation of legal remedies was necessary to protect the financial interests of the European Union.
In its annual report released last year, eu-LISA made its intentions clear. The document stated that following various delays in the delivery of the EES by the contracting consortium, the agency had activated available contractual and legal remedies. This culminated on December 22, 2025, with the submission of a formal claim to the Estonian Court, where eu-LISA is headquartered.
The agency has been careful to distinguish between the development of the system and its current functionality. A spokesperson for eu-LISA confirmed that the legal proceedings concern the development phase and do not impact the current operation of the EES. "eu-LISA confirms that legal proceedings have been initiated against the consortium, in line with the Agency’s responsibility to protect the EU’s financial interests," the spokesperson stated. "As the proceedings are ongoing, we do not comment on the details of the case. The EES is fully operational."
The Transition to New Leadership
The friction between eu-LISA and the original consortium eventually led to a change in the project’s stewardship. The initial contract with IBM Belgium, Atos Belgium, and Leonardo was not renewed last year. Instead, the responsibility for the system’s continued evolution and maintenance was handed over to a new group of firms.
As of this summer, Sword Systems, Netcompany, and Sopra Steria have taken over the contract. This shift in personnel marks a significant attempt by the EU to move past the troubled development phase and stabilize the system’s performance. However, the legacy of the initial delays remains a matter for the courts, as the EU seeks accountability for the resources and time lost during the first several years of the project.
While the new contractors inherit a system that is now "fully operational," they also inherit the challenge of refining a technology that has already damaged the reputation of European border management among international travelers and the aviation industry.
