November 22, 2026

WIPO Panel Finds Danish Green Energy Firm Guilty of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking Over windspace.com

In a significant rebuke of what is often referred to in the legal community as "Plan B" litigation, a World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) panel has found Danish green energy firm WindSpace A/S guilty of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking (RDNH). The decision, handed down by Panelist Sebastian Hughes, follows the complainant’s repeated and ultimately unsuccessful attempts to purchase the domain name windspace.com through traditional commercial negotiations spanning more than a decade.

The case, which involved representation by the Denmark office of the global law firm DLA Piper, highlights a growing trend of corporate entities attempting to use the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) as a tool for coercive acquisition after failing to secure a domain on the open market. In this instance, the panelist determined that WindSpace A/S not only failed to meet the necessary legal criteria for a cybersquatting claim but also pursued the case despite clear evidence that the domain owner had legitimate rights and had registered the asset years before the complainant even existed.

The Origins of the Dispute and the History of windspace.com

The roots of the conflict date back to the very early era of the commercial internet. The disputed domain name, windspace.com, was first registered in 1999. At that time, the complainant, WindSpace A/S, was not a functioning entity; the company would not commence its business operations for another seven years.

According to the case record, the domain name has a long and documented history of use within the renewable energy sector. Rather than being held by a "squatter" looking for a quick payout, the domain was owned by a succession of green energy companies. These ownership changes were not the result of speculative flipping but were instead the byproduct of corporate acquisitions and transitions within the industry.

At the time the dispute reached the WIPO panel, the respondent was using the domain in connection with an independent business known as Terranova, which operates within the Spanish renewable energy market. This history of industry-specific use proved to be a critical factor in the panel’s determination that the respondent possessed legitimate interests in the name.

A Decade of Failed Negotiations

The evidence presented in the case revealed that WindSpace A/S was well aware of the domain’s value and its rightful ownership long before it decided to file a legal claim. The complainant first approached the respondent with an offer to purchase windspace.com in September 2009. At that time, the respondent was actively using the domain for its business operations and promptly rejected the inquiry.

Undeterred by the initial refusal, WindSpace A/S made a second attempt to acquire the domain in 2014. When that too was rejected, the company waited several more years before making a third and final offer in 2022. After thirteen years of intermittent negotiations and three failed attempts to buy the domain at a price or under terms acceptable to the owner, the complainant shifted its strategy from the boardroom to the legal arena.

This transition from negotiation to litigation is what domain industry experts often call "Plan B." When a company cannot convince a domain owner to sell, it may attempt to use the UDRP to force a transfer by alleging cybersquatting. However, the UDRP is designed to protect trademark holders from bad-faith registration, not to act as a fallback mechanism for failed commercial transactions.

The Panel’s Findings on Bad Faith and Legitimate Interests

To succeed in a UDRP claim, a complainant must prove three distinct elements: that the domain is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark in which they have rights; that the respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in the domain; and that the domain was registered and is being used in bad faith.

Panelist Sebastian Hughes found that WindSpace A/S failed decisively on the second and third prongs of this test. The evidence of the respondent’s long-standing use of the domain in the Spanish renewable energy sector made it impossible for the complainant to argue that the owner lacked a legitimate interest.

More importantly, the panelist addressed the requirement of bad faith registration. Under the UDRP, a complainant must generally show that the respondent had the complainant’s trademark in mind when they registered the domain. Because windspace.com was registered in 1999—seven years before WindSpace A/S began operations and nearly a decade before it secured its Danish trademark rights—it was chronologically impossible for the respondent to have registered the domain in bad faith against the complainant.

Green energy company tries UDRP after three failed purchase attempts

In his written decision, Hughes noted that the term "WindSpace" itself carries a natural meaning within the renewable energy sector, further justifying its use by multiple parties in the industry. He concluded that the complainant should have recognized that it could not meet the established requirements for a finding of bad faith, particularly regarding the theory of "passive holding," which is sometimes used when a domain is not in active use. Here, the domain was not only registered early but had also been used for legitimate business purposes.

The Ruling of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking

The most stinging portion of the decision was the formal finding of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking. RDNH is defined under the UDRP Rules as "using the Policy in bad faith to attempt to deprive a registered domain-name holder of a domain name." While it does not carry financial penalties within the WIPO framework, it serves as a public "shaming" mechanism and can be used as evidence in future court proceedings.

Panelist Hughes was direct in his admonishment of WindSpace A/S and its legal counsel. He wrote:

"In all the circumstances, the Panel finds the Complainant ought to have been aware that it would be unable to establish bad faith registration and use, as the disputed domain name was registered seven years before the Complainant commenced business, and almost ten years before the Complainant obtained its Danish registered rights in the Trade Mark."

The panelist further emphasized that the complainant’s own history of trying to buy the domain worked against its legal claims. By making offers to purchase the domain over a 13-year period and seeing those offers rejected by a party using the domain for a real business, the complainant was fully aware that the respondent was not a cybersquatter.

"The Complainant also ought to have been aware that, in light of the Respondent’s refusal to countenance its three offers to purchase the disputed domain name… the Complainant would be unable to establish bad faith," Hughes noted.

DLA Piper and the Pattern of RDNH Findings

The fact that WindSpace A/S was represented by DLA Piper’s Denmark office added an extra layer of scrutiny to the case. DLA Piper is one of the largest and most prestigious law firms in the world, and its attorneys are expected to be well-versed in the nuances of domain name law and the UDRP process.

This is not the first time DLA Piper’s Danish branch has been involved in a case that resulted in an RDNH finding. The firm previously represented the complainant in the Normann Copenhagen case, which similarly ended with a panel determining that the UDRP was being used inappropriately.

The recurrence of such findings against the same legal office raises questions about the vetting process for UDRP complaints. Legal experts often point out that experienced counsel should be able to identify "dead on arrival" cases—those where the domain registration clearly predates the trademark—and advise their clients against filing a claim that could lead to an RDNH ruling.

Broader Implications for the Domain Industry

The WindSpace A/S decision serves as a cautionary tale for brands and their legal representatives. It reaffirms that the UDRP is a narrow tool intended to combat clear cases of bad-faith squatting, not a shortcut for acquiring valuable digital real estate that is already in use by another legitimate business.

The case also highlights the importance of the "first-in-time, first-in-right" principle that often governs domain name disputes when no bad faith is present. For companies in the renewable energy sector, where many names are descriptive or composed of common industry terms like "wind," "solar," or "space," the bar for proving exclusive rights is significantly higher.

As the digital economy continues to expand, the value of legacy .com domains registered in the 1990s only increases. This case demonstrates that even a decade of frustration in the marketplace does not grant a company the right to bypass the rules of the UDRP to seize an asset it could not buy. For the owner of windspace.com, the decision provides a definitive end to years of unwanted solicitations and a firm validation of their long-term ownership of the domain.