As the global domain name industry prepares for the next significant expansion of the internet’s root zone, several applicants for new Top-Level Domains (gTLDs) have begun to proactively withdraw or modify their applications. This movement comes as companies attempt to align their proposals with the rigorous standards set forth in the ICANN Applicant Guidebook, particularly regarding geographic protections and string similarity. By dropping or swapping potentially problematic strings now, these applicants are seeking to avoid the costly and time-consuming disputes that characterized previous rounds of domain expansion.
The current atmosphere in the domain industry is one of cautious navigation. ICANN, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, has established a complex set of criteria that every new gTLD application must meet. Among the most stringent of these are the rules governing geographic names. According to the current framework, any applied-for string that matches a recognized geographic entity—ranging from major cities to sub-national administrative divisions—requires explicit approval from the relevant local government or authority. This rule is designed to prevent private entities from monopolizing terms that have significant public interest or sovereign importance to specific regions, cultures, or nations.
The scope of these geographic protections is broad, covering names that appear on several international standardized lists. This includes strings that match cities or sub-national place names, such as counties, states, and provinces, found on the ISO 3166-2 list. Furthermore, names that correspond to UNESCO regions or United Nations M49 geographic regions are also subject to these requirements. Because the ISO 3166-2 list is exhaustive, it often includes common words that also happen to serve as the names of administrative districts in various parts of the world. This creates a hidden minefield for applicants who may believe they are applying for a generic dictionary term, only to find that the term is also a protected geographic identifier.
Recent filings indicate that several applicants have identified these risks and opted to drop their applications for certain strings rather than attempt to secure the necessary governmental permissions. While the specific list of all dropped names continues to evolve as the application window progresses, the trend highlights a growing awareness of the difficulties involved in bypassing geographic objections. For many applicants, the realization that a chosen string is essentially "off-limits" without a letter of support from a foreign government is enough to prompt a strategic withdrawal.
Beyond geographic concerns, the issue of string similarity is also forcing applicants to reconsider their portfolios. ICANN’s rules are intended to prevent consumer confusion by ensuring that new TLDs are not too similar to existing ones or to other pending applications. This includes a prohibition on strings that are confusingly similar in appearance, sound, or meaning, as well as specific scrutiny regarding singular and plural versions of the same word.
In a notable example of this regulatory caution, the entity Index Internet recently opted to swap out its application for .praxis. The decision appears to be a preemptive move to avoid a conflict with the existing "dot-brand" TLD, .praxi. In the eyes of ICANN’s evaluators and the broader community, .praxis could easily be interpreted as a singular or alternative version of .praxi, leading to potential rejection or a formal objection from the brand owner. By making this change early, Index Internet avoids the risk of a protracted "String Similarity Review" that could have derailed their efforts.
Despite these voluntary withdrawals, a significant number of strings remain in the current application pool that could still trigger geographic requirements. Many of these have been filed as generic applications, yet they appear on the ISO 3166-2 list or other protected registries. Industry observers are paying close attention to several high-profile applications that sit on this regulatory fence. Specifically, applications for the strings .north, .west, and .central are under intense scrutiny.

The registrar and registry service provider XYZ has applied for all three of these cardinal-direction strings, while Endpoint Domains has also submitted an application for .central. While these terms are undeniably generic in English, they also function as names for various sub-national regions and administrative divisions globally. Under the current Applicant Guidebook, if ICANN determines that these strings are primarily geographic in nature—or if a government asserts its rights over the name—the applicants may be forced to either produce government support or face the cancellation of their applications. The outcome for .north, .west, and .central will likely serve as a bellwether for how strictly ICANN intends to enforce geographic protections for generic-sounding terms in this round.
The potential for conflict does not end with cardinal directions. Other strings currently under review, such as .pool and .mono, might also be captured by geographic rules. In some jurisdictions, these terms serve as the names of specific regions or administrative units. The challenge for ICANN is to determine whether the average internet user would associate the TLD with the generic meaning of the word or with the specific geographic location. For the applicants, the risk is that a single government objection based on these lists can halt an application that has already cost hundreds of thousands of dollars in fees and legal preparation.
In addition to geographic and similarity issues, the current phase of the new gTLD program allows for a period of public scrutiny and formal objections. One of the most contentious areas remains the relationship between singular and plural versions of TLDs. During the 2012 round of gTLD expansion, ICANN faced significant criticism for allowing both singular and plural versions of the same word to coexist in the root zone—such as .loan and .loans, or .gift and .gifts. Critics argued that this created unnecessary confusion for users and increased the potential for phishing and intellectual property infringement.
For the "Next Round" of applications, ICANN has signaled a more cautious approach, but the community remains vigilant. Members of the public and competing applicants have a 30-day window to file notices with ICANN if they believe an applied-for string is a singular or plural version of an existing TLD. This mechanism is intended to provide a "safety valve" for the industry to police itself and ensure that the root zone remains navigable and clear for the general public.
The window for formal application comments is currently open and is scheduled to remain so until March 17. This period is a critical time for the domain name ecosystem, as it allows stakeholders—including trademark owners, governments, and other registry operators—to voice their concerns about specific applications. The comments submitted during this time can influence the Geographic Names Panel and the String Similarity Panel, potentially leading to further withdrawals or forced modifications of applications.
For the applicants, the stakes are high. The cost of applying for a new gTLD is substantial, involving not only the initial ICANN application fee but also the long-term operational costs of running a registry. Withdrawing an application early may allow for a partial refund of fees, whereas losing a formal objection process later can result in the total loss of the investment. This financial reality is driving the "self-cleansing" of the application list currently being observed.
As the March 17 deadline approaches, the industry is bracing for a flurry of activity. The notices filed regarding singular and plural versions, as well as the formal comments regarding geographic concerns, will shape the final list of TLDs that move forward into the deep technical and financial evaluation phases. The proactive steps taken by applicants like Index Internet and those dropping geographic strings suggest a more mature and risk-averse approach to this round of expansion compared to the "land grab" mentality often seen in the past.
The evolution of these applications reflects the ongoing tension between the commercial desire for short, memorable, and generic domain extensions and the international community’s requirement to protect geographic and cultural identities. Whether .north, .west, and .central will survive the geographic review remains to be seen, but the current wave of withdrawals proves that the Applicant Guidebook’s rules are being taken more seriously than ever by those hoping to operate the next generation of the internet’s infrastructure.
