However, the Garante rejected this argument. The Italian regulator clarified that the "one-stop-shop" mechanism applies to the GDPR but does not extend to the ePrivacy Directive. Because the breach involved Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code (the local version of ePrivacy rules), the Italian authority maintained its jurisdiction to investigate and penalize the company directly for violations occurring within its borders.

The financial magnitude of the fine—equivalent to approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue—was calculated based on several aggravating factors. The Garante took into account the sheer scale of the infringement, noting that approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were affected by the feature. The duration of the breach was also a primary consideration; the feature has been available since 2023, and the authority noted that the breach remains ongoing for users who have not updated their apps or who previously granted permissions under the misleading interface.
Furthermore, the regulator cited a 2019 decision against Meta and what it described as limited cooperation during the investigative process as reasons for the high penalty. While Meta did implement some changes to the app after the initial complaint was filed, the Garante judged these efforts as "late" and insufficient, as they only benefited users who actively updated their software to the latest version.
As part of the enforcement action, the Garante has issued a strict set of requirements that Meta must fulfill within a 60-day window. The company is mandated to switch off the gallery suggestion feature by default for all Italian users. This order applies even to individuals who have previously granted the app access to their galleries. Meta must now seek consent for this specific feature separately and transparently, ensuring that users are fully aware of what they are agreeing to.
If Meta fails to meet the 60-day deadline, the regulator has stipulated that the feature must be completely disabled for any user who has not provided valid, informed consent under the new requirements.
This case serves as a significant precedent for how national regulators in Europe can leverage ePrivacy laws to bypass the centralized "one-stop-shop" system of the GDPR when it comes to the protection of data stored on personal devices. It also underscores the increasing scrutiny on "dark patterns" and default settings that nudge users into sharing more data than they might otherwise intend. For Meta, the ruling represents not only a substantial financial hit but also a mandatory overhaul of one of its core user-engagement features in a major European market. As the 60-day compliance clock begins to tick, the tech industry will be watching closely to see how Meta adjusts its interface to satisfy the Italian authorities while balancing its global product strategy.
