November 22, 2026

AuDA plans to grandfather existing .com.au and .net.au registrants

The controversy began when the auDA board recently approved a series of restrictive changes to the licensing rules governing who can hold a .com.au or .net.au address. At the heart of the dispute was the decision to remove a long-standing regulatory pillar known as the "close and substantial connection" test. For decades, this test allowed Australian businesses and organizations to register domain names that were not an exact match for their registered business name or trademark, provided they could demonstrate a clear and relevant link to the domain in question. This flexibility was essential for companies that marketed specific products, services, or seasonal campaigns under descriptive URLs.

Under the proposed new rules, however, this flexibility was slated to disappear. The new criteria would have required a much more rigid and literal connection between the registrant’s legal identity and the domain name itself. To illustrate the potential impact, industry observers pointed to a hypothetical but common scenario: a registered business named "Jane’s Bakery" that specializes in a popular line of apple pies. Under the historical "close and substantial connection" rules, Jane’s Bakery could easily justify and register the domain "applepies.com.au" to promote its primary product. Under the board’s newly approved (but now partially rolled back) restrictive framework, such a registration would likely be prohibited because "apple pies" is not the legal name of the entity.

The implications of such a change were vast. If the "close and substantial connection" test were removed without any protections for existing users, millions of Australian businesses could have found themselves in a position where their domain names were no longer compliant with auDA policy. This would have potentially led to the cancellation of registrations, the loss of years of search engine optimization (SEO) value, and the total disruption of established email communications and online branding. The "chopping block" for these domains was not merely a theoretical concern but a looming reality for a significant portion of Australia’s digital economy.

The push for these stricter rules did not go unchallenged within auDA’s own leadership. Erhan Karabardak, a prominent intellectual property attorney and a former member of the auDA board, was a vocal critic of the policy shift. Despite serving on the panel that initially reviewed and recommended the rule changes, Karabardak ultimately voted against the proposal, citing the severe risks it posed to the stability of the Australian domain ecosystem.

Speaking on the Domain Name Wire Podcast, Karabardak elaborated on the stakes involved for registrants. He highlighted that the "close and substantial connection" rule provided a necessary bridge between the legal formalities of business registration and the practical realities of digital marketing. By removing that bridge, auDA risked alienating the very businesses it is meant to serve, creating a bureaucratic environment where common-sense registrations were barred in favor of an overly narrow interpretation of eligibility.

The reaction from the broader industry was equally swift and critical. Domain name registrars—the commercial entities that interface directly with the public to sell and manage domain names—became a primary source of pushback. These registrars were faced with the prospect of having to tell long-term clients that their web addresses were suddenly invalid, an administrative and customer-service nightmare that threatened to undermine confidence in the .au namespace. Registrars argued that the changes would not only hurt individual businesses but would also diminish the overall value and growth of the .com.au and .net.au extensions.

auDA plans to grandfather existing .com.au and .net.au registrants

Faced with this mounting pressure from legal experts, industry stakeholders, and the registrar community, auDA has now moved to mitigate the damage. In a statement released this week, the organization announced its plan to grandfather existing registrants. This means that businesses and individuals who currently hold .com.au and .net.au domains under the previous rules will be allowed to maintain and renew those registrations, even if they would not meet the stricter criteria being implemented for new applicants. This plan is currently pending final board approval, but it represents a significant tactical retreat for the regulator.

While the decision to grandfather existing domains saves current owners from immediate disaster, the long-term outlook for the .com.au and .net.au extensions remains complicated. The updated, stricter rules are still expected to apply to all new registrations. Industry analysts warn that this could severely stunt the growth of these traditional extensions. New businesses or existing companies launching new products will find it much harder to secure descriptive or category-killer domain names within the .com.au space. If a new startup cannot register a domain that reflects its product because of these rigid naming requirements, it may look elsewhere for its digital home.

This policy shift occurs at a time when the Australian domain landscape is already undergoing significant transformation. In recent years, auDA introduced second-level .au registrations—often referred to as "direct .au" domains (such as "example.au" instead of "example.com.au"). These direct registrations were not impacted by the controversial rule changes surrounding the "close and substantial connection" test. Some observers suggest that the move to tighten the rules for .com.au may have been an attempt to streamline the namespace or perhaps inadvertently drive more users toward the shorter, newer .au extension. However, the .com.au suffix remains the "gold standard" for Australian commerce, and any policy that makes it harder to use could drive Australian entrepreneurs toward the global .com extension, thereby weakening the local digital sovereign space.

The grandfathering provision acts as a vital safety net, preserving the status quo for the millions of businesses that have built their reputations on the .com.au and .net.au platforms. It acknowledges that a domain name is more than just a technical address; it is a piece of digital property and a cornerstone of a business’s identity. By protecting these existing assets, auDA is attempting to balance its desire for a more structured regulatory framework with the practical necessity of maintaining market stability.

However, the decision also creates a "two-tier" system within the Australian domain market. Existing registrants will enjoy a level of flexibility that will be denied to new market entrants. This disparity could create a secondary market where older, "grandfathered" domains become highly prized assets because they carry naming rights that can no longer be obtained through standard registration channels. It remains to be seen how auDA will handle the transfer of these grandfathered domains in the future—specifically whether a domain loses its grandfathered status when it is sold or transferred to a new owner. If the grandfathered status does not "run with the domain," the value of these assets could be significantly impacted during business acquisitions.

As the auDA board moves toward a final vote on these measures, the industry continues to watch closely. The organization’s willingness to listen to feedback and adjust its course suggests a recognition of the complexities involved in governing a national resource like the .au ccTLD. For now, the millions of "applepies.com.au" owners across the country can breathe a little easier, knowing that their digital storefronts are no longer in the immediate line of fire. Yet, the broader conversation about how to keep the Australian domain space competitive, flexible, and relevant in a globalized internet remains more urgent than ever. The balance between strict regulatory oversight and the needs of a dynamic commercial environment is a delicate one, and this latest update from auDA represents just the latest chapter in that ongoing negotiation.